G.17: Design and evaluate positive and negative punishment (e.g., time-out, response cost, overcorrection).
Free practice questions for this part of the BCBA, with an explanation for every option.
In a group home, a resident loses two earned tokens each time he curses at staff. Cursing decreases over three weeks. Which procedure is this?
- A. ExtinctionExtinction withholds the maintaining reinforcer. It does not remove other reinforcers the person already has.
- B. Response costCorrect. Contingent loss of a specific amount of a reinforcer the person holds, followed by a decrease in behavior, is response cost (negative punishment).
- C. Positive punishmentPositive punishment involves adding a stimulus after the behavior.
- D. Exclusionary time-outTime-out removes access to reinforcement for a period of time. It does not remove specific reinforcers the person already has.
A teacher uses exclusionary time-out (sending the student to a hallway desk) for disruptive behavior during difficult reading tasks. Disruption has increased since time-out started. What is the most likely explanation?
- A. The time-out duration is too short and should be extended to 30 minutesMaking the time-out longer would give more escape and could strengthen disruption further.
- B. The student is showing an extinction burst, which will pass with continued time-outTime-out is not extinction, and the steady increase fits reinforcement better than a temporary burst.
- C. Time-out was not explained clearly enough before it was usedExplaining the procedure does not change its function, which is escape from the task.
- D. Disruption is probably escape-maintained, so time-out negatively reinforces it by removing the student from the reading taskCorrect. Time-out works only when the time-in environment is more reinforcing. For behavior that functions to escape the task, removing the student from the task reinforces the behavior.
After writing graffiti on one bathroom wall, a student is required to scrub off his own writing and also clean the graffiti from every other wall in the bathroom. This procedure is best described as:
- A. Restitutional overcorrectionCorrect. Restitutional overcorrection requires restoring the damaged environment to a condition better than it was before the behavior.
- B. Positive practice overcorrectionPositive practice involves repeated practice of a correct form of the behavior, not restoring the environment.
- C. Response blockingResponse blocking physically stops the behavior while it is happening.
- D. Contingent exerciseContingent exercise requires effortful physical activity that has nothing to do with the misbehavior.